I think you always have a better chance if you start with your own domain name. That's not to say you couldn't get good rankings with your AOL site but it looks much better when you own your own space. Plus other webmasters may not take you serious or link to you and getting links to your site is a very important part of mastering the search engines.
__________________
Don't put the cart before the horse. Plan your website, thencreate it.